Black Tap’s Peeps Milkshake Is The Ultimate Easter Sugar Overload

Photo courtesy of Black Tap.

This single milkshake is the ultimate Easter-themed sugar rush.

Black Tap, the New York City burger spot known for its insane milkshake creations, unveiled an Easter-themed Peeps milkshake that snags the occasion’s theme and flips it on its sugary head.

This colossal sugar overload, known as The PEEPS Shake, features a wild cherry shake as the base for all of the crazy toppings and decorations it comes with. The glass is coated in a vanilla frosting and a layer of Easter sprinkles is rolled onto the frosting.

The shake doesn’t stop there, as it gets topped off with a multitude of PEEPs delights, Easter bunny lollipops, whipped cream, and even more sprinkles. Just one sip of this is enough to get you wired through Easter weekend.

If you’re down to grab one of these massive shake creations, all of the NYC Black Tap locations will be selling it exclusively on Easter Sunday, April 16th. The shake will cost $15, but will easily be enough for multiple people to partake in.

I can’t think of a sweeter way out there to celebrate Easter this year.

More content

Eating Out
Taco Bell’s New Flamin’ Hot Grilled Cheese Burrito Is Their Spiciest Move Yet
Taco Bell is taking things up a few thousand Scovilles with the debut of the Flamin’ Hot Grilled Cheese Burrito—a fiery remix of a cult…
,
Eating Out
Little Caesars Is Testing A Cheesy Garlic Pizza That’s Pure Comfort Food Energy
Little Caesars is testing something dangerously craveable—a Cheesy Garlic Pizza that’s basically what happens when garlic bread and pizza decide to move in together. The…
,
Eating Out
Krispy Kreme Lost $441 Million Last Quarter—Here’s What Went Wrong
In one of the more unexpected financial headlines this year, Krispy Kreme reported a net loss of $441.1 million in its second quarter of 2025.…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox