Watch Seth Rogen Taste Test Secret Menu Burgers

Seth Rogen is arguably one of the funniest men on the planet, so you know he’s going to have his mind blown in a hilarious way when trying new food.

On First We Feast’s latest episode of The Burger Show, host Alvin Cailan made Rogen choose between the Tupac and Biggies of the burger world.

Trying both In-N-Out’s Animal Style Burger,\ and Shake Shack’s Peanut Butter and Bacon Shackburger, Rogen reviewed and made a choice between the two secret menu items.

Rogen, a true gentleman and scholar, chose California’s Animal Style Burger over the East Coast burger. The convincing point seemed to be In-N-Out’s chopped chilies, as the  comedian said they were a revelation and added a dimension to In-N-Out that he didn’t know existed.

Is the debate between In-N-Out and Shake Shack now settled through the words of Seth Rogen? Probably not.  Fans will forever fight over the two burger spots. It also didn’t help that Rogen said he once got food poisoning from In-N-Out, but he did say he immediately went back, because In-N-Out is worth it.

More content

CultureEating Out
McDonald’s New Happy Meal Comes With Mini Crocs And Jibbitz
The 2026 McDonald’s All American Games, which pits the nation’s best high school basketball players against one another, tips off at Desert Diamond Arena in…
,
CultureEating Out
Pizza Hut Drops Space Jam Boxes And March Madness Merch
Pizza Hut is leaning all the way into March Madness this year, and somehow Bugs Bunny is involved. To celebrate the 30th anniversary of Space…
,
CultureEating Out
AMC’s Devil Wears Prada Popcorn Bucket Is Literally A Designer Purse
Fashionistas rejoice! The long-awaited sequel to The Devil Wears Prada arrives in theaters on April 30, and to celebrate, AMC wants you to snack in…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox