Mafia War Almost Breaks Out Because of Sauce Recipe

New Yorkers take their pizza seriously. You can eat a slice of pepperoni pizza at 100 different pizza places and get 100 different tastes.

A lot of it is in the sauce, so it is understandable why a ruckus could be created when one pizzeria accuses a rival of stealing its pizza sauce recipe.

The Colombo mafia, which was associated with L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn, accused Eugene Lombardo of the Bonanno crime family of stealing one of its sauce recipes.

Lombardo has a restaurant of his own in Staten Island called The Square where the Colombos believed their sauce was being used. Only during a sit-down at Panera Bread were these two sides able to come to terms, but not before some serious tension.

According to court testimony, the story went as follows:

Lombardo’s sons worked at L&B and associate Frank Guerra said he saw Lombardo’s sons eyeing some of the flour supplies in the basement. Former Colombo crime boss Anthony Russo was alerted as he, Guerra and Colombo member Frank Iannaci went to the rival Square restaurant to confront them of their wrongdoings. Upon arrival, there was a sign on the front window of The Square that read, “L&B style pizza” which had to have pushed the three over the edge.

After a heated argument, people being called, “pieces of s–t” and Lombardo being slapped in the face by Iannaci, the two rival sides decided to further discuss the matter at a Staten Island Panera Bread. Some money changed hands ($4,000 to the Colombos) and nobody got hurt.

It is not unusual to see meetings held at Panera Bread, but there might never be that much tension surrounding a bowl of clam chowder again.

[Thx Daily Mail]

More content

Eating Out
George Lucas’ Long-Awaited Museum Is Getting Its Own Skywalker-Inspired Restaurant
On Tuesday, September 22, 2026, the long-awaited Lucas Museum of Narrative Art is set to open on Vermont Avenue in Los Angeles’ Exposition Park, and…
,
Eating Out
Domino’s Launches A Detroit-Style Pizza That Looks Like An Actual Domino
Domino’s has spent more than 60 years putting its name on pizza boxes. Somehow, it took until 2026 to put an actual domino inside one.…
,
InnovationProducts
Someone Invented A Beer Glass That Punishes You For Forgetting To Drink Water
We’ve all heard the responsible drinking advice before: Have some water between beers. Pace yourself. Hydrate. All sensible suggestions that become considerably easier to forget…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox