Blue Moon Ditches Iconic Orange Slice For a Mini Pie As Garnish

After 27 years of garnishing its beers with orange wheels, Blue Moon Brewing Company has decided that the sunny citrus has lost its “a-peel” and is ditching it for something sweeter.

For a limited time this holiday season, Blue Moon is swapping its signature fruit ornament and replacing it with pie via its Blue Moon Pie Pints. Blue Moon brewers partnered with Baked by Melissa’s Melissa Ben-Ishay to craft three pie recipes created to pair with their beers.

  • Spiced Citrus Pumpkin Pie: For its signature Blue Moon Belgian White Belgian-Style Wheat Ale, Ben-Ishay focused on a Thanksgiving classic. The Spiced Citrus Pumpkin Pie incorporates dashes of coriander and orange zest that compliment the subtle sweetness and bright, citrus aroma of the beer.
  • Tropic Sky Pie: For LightSky, she created a pastry packed with a mango and pineapple custard filling that compliments the flavors of LightSky Citrus Wheat and Tropical Wheat.
  • Coconut Citrus Pie: For Moon Haze, the focus was on citrus and coconut flavors to balance its hoppiness and juicy flavor profile.

“Blue Moon’s orange wheel garnish is so iconic it would take something special for us to even consider replacing it,” said Leah Bowman, Associate Marketing Manager at Molson Coors Beverage Company. “As a leader in the mini baked goods space, Melissa Ben-Ishay was the perfect fit to create mini seasonal pie pints recipes that not only pair with each beer, but elevate the table and palate alike.”

“Whenever I come up with a new cupcake flavor or write a new recipe, I’m focused on getting the perfect bite. With the Blue Moon Pie Pints, you get the perfect bite and sip!” said Melissa Ben-Ishay, CEO and co-founder of Baked by Melissa.

Now through Friday, November 11, fans can buy a limited quantity of Blue Moon Pie Pints three-packs per day at BlueMoonPiePints.com. Every Blue Moon Pie Pint is baked fresh by the bakers at Brooklyn-based bakery, Pie Corps. 

You can also enter for a chance to win Blue Moon Pie Pints shipped directly to your door at BlueMoonPiePints.com/enter. And for those who would rather craft Blue Moon’s Pie Pints at home, recipes can be found online at BlueMoonPiePints.com/recipes.

More content

Eating Out
White Castle Joins The Dirty Soda Craze With Two New Fizzy Creations
White Castle, America’s first fast food hamburger chain—famous for serving up hot and tasty sliders since 1921—is rolling out a new kind of refreshment: Dirty…
,
Products
Lemonade-Flavored Chips Have Entered The Chat—Are Tastebuds Ready?
Potato chip maker Utz Brands has linked with Alex’s Lemonade Stand Foundation, a charity for childhood cancer research, to release a limited-edition Lemonade Potato Chip…
,
Culture
This Man Once Ate A Whole Costco Chicken In Front Of 1,000 Fans—Now He’s Back For Round Two
On May 1st, 2025, UCSD Costco Club founder and president Johnathan Gong faces off against an entire rotisserie chicken. The epic event takes place at…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox