Why Canned Cranberry Is — And Always Will Be — Better Than Fresh

Every so often in our post-foodist world, I get this overwhelming urge to eat, well, shit. Not actual fecal matter (ew), but certainly foods a few higher-minded cohorts might readily scoff at. Let’s be real, preserved, pasteurized, processed to the point of being unrecognizable, “shit” was the kind of cuisine we were raised on — none of this locally sourced, organic, artisan-crafted bullshit, but fruit “salads” made with baby marshmallows and Cool Whip, and jellied cranberry served straight from the can. (Thanks mom.) It’s why, after years of trying gourmet frou frou versions like chili cranberry gastrique and cabernet cranberry chutneys, I’ll happily still let good old Ocean Spray take up precious space on my Thanksgiving platter.

Here’s why canned cranberry is — and always will be — better than fresh:

_______________

It’s nostalgic.

Like I said, canned is what I grew up with, and canned is what my children will grow up with. There is no joy quite like jiggling a perfectly intact cylinder of ribbed red gelatin onto a plate and then slicing it into individual rounds. (Mushed jelly, on the other hand, is for heathens. Totally defeats the purpose.)

PicThx CTR6

_______________

It’s sweeter.

c2

Says Dr. Gourmet, cranberries are not naturally sweet, so while 100 grams of fresh ones contain only around 50 calories, their processed, saucy counterparts contain as much as 151 — holiday indulgence, indeed.

_______________

It’s actually cheaper than making it from scratch.

c3

According to a 2011 article in Bon Appetit, store-bought cranberry sauce comes out to $1.26 per cup, while homemade costs $2.93 per cup. Why cause unnecessary suffering?

PicThx Wired

_______________

It’s also just way easier to make (or, rather, not make.)

c4

There’s already so much other work to be done on Thanksgiving, between thawing and frying the turkey, and dodging your relatives’ awkward dating questions. If everyone’s just as happy with canned as with homemade, why fuss?

Picthx justinbaeder

_______________

And it doesn’t mix with my mashed potatoes and turkey when I don’t want it to.

c5

Thank you, you ruby-colored, self-containing goop!

PicThx purpleslog

_______________

I mean, fresh cranberry isn’t bad . . .

c6

At times it can even be delicious.

PicThx Messy Apron

_______________

Like here.

c8

PicThx Half Baked Harvest

_______________

And here.

c9

PicThx Food Charlatan

_______________

And it’s not like I’d eat canned cranberries any other day of the year — that’d just be weird.

c10

(Leftover turkey sandwiches notwithstanding.)

PicThx Hunger and Thirst for Life

_______________

But I will always, always love the canned stuff.

c11

PicThx Gretta Johns

_______________

 And anyone who looks down on it is sorely missing out.

c12

PicThx Bon Appetit

_______________

So jiggle on, you beautiful burgundy bastard. Jiggle on.

PicThx izismile

_______________

Here’s to 101 more jiggly years!

(Just because, fun fact: the first commercial canned cranberry was introduced in 1912.)

Lead Picthx Robert S. Donovan

More content

Products
Snoop Dogg Will Pay You $10K A Month To Taste Ice Cream
Finding out that Snoop Dogg has a family-owned ice cream company and is currently looking for an official ice cream taste tester was not on…
,
Culture
Craig Robinson Reveals Just How Much Food Actors Get On TV Sets
Craig Robinson is someone you know, even if you weren’t paying attention to his memorably hilarious and zany characters in classic shows like The Office…
,
Products
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Is Getting A ‘Swicy’ Chamoy Makeover
This might be the most unexpected fusion-ha! of 2026. Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Chamoy Mega, the #1 chamoy brand in the U.S. and Mexico, are…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox