Now Peeps Oreos Are Turning People’s Poop Pink

When Oreo debuted its Peeps flavor recently, people had mild complaints about the cookie turning their tongues and saliva pink.

Whatever. Slurpees do that all that time and it’s not a big deal.

There are new complaints about the Oreo, though, as people are now saying it’s turning their poop as pink as Jigglypuff’s belly.

The pink cream inside the Oreo contains a dye called FD&C Red No. 3, and apparently doesn’t break down during digestion according to Live Science. That could be the main reason why it comes out the backdoor looking like Kirby.

A lot of us in the Foodbeast office got down on these Oreos and didn’t notice such side effects, but then again, no one ate a whole pack’s worth:

Even Charmin toilet paper brilliantly chimed in on the Peeps Oreos, offering discreet help to its victims:

While it’s a strange side effect, at least no one’s getting sick. Still, get your shit together, Oreo.

More content

Eating Out
Reese’s Is Turning Its Iconic Halloween Pumpkin Into A Latte
Pumpkin spice season has become virtually unavoidable, but Reese’s has found a loophole: make a pumpkin latte without any actual pumpkin. Reese’s is teaming up…
,
Eating Out
White Castle Is Celebrating Football Season By Putting Beer Cheese On Everything
Two Columbus originals are linking up for football season, and naturally, beer cheese is involved. White Castle and Garage Beer have teamed up on a…
,
Eating Out
Sonic Just Went All-In On 2026’s Biggest Flavor Trend
The great banana takeover of 2026 continues, and Sonic is the latest chain to go all in. Banana has become one of the year’s biggest…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox