Harry Potter Cookie with Hogwarts Acceptance Letter Hidden Inside

During the height of the Potter craze, most of us wanted nothing more than to receive that Hogwarts acceptance letter in the mail. We would’ve chosen that over our top college pick any day and taken a chance to leave our muggle lives behind in a heartbeat. While those days are now past, this Hogwarts cookie with a letter awaiting inside offers tasty consolation.

Made by Tina of Sugar Bean Bakers for a friend’s birthday, the recipe calls for just a few easy steps. The cookie itself consist of a simple sugar cookie recipe, then gets topped with marshmallow fondant. The “official” Hogwarts acceptance letter is folded and placed inside beforehand, making a delightful surprise for any Potter fan.

For those of you still waiting by the mailbox for that fateful day, these Hogwarts Acceptance Letter Cookies will hold you over ’til then.

H/T + PicThx Sugar Bean Bakers

More content

Products
Olipop Is Giving Away Soda-Scented Wrapping Paper For The Holidays
Olipop is a prebiotic soda brand that’s been shaking up the beverage industry, known for its high fiber content, with only 2 to 5 grams…
,
CultureRecipes
A Cheez-It–Crusted Turkey Leg Will Be Served At The Citrus Bowl
Prince Cheddward, Cheez-It’s royal mascot, will be cheese-pulling up to this year’s Cheez-It Citrus Bowl. He’s come out of retirement to retake the throne as…
,
Products
Goldfish Is Kicking Off 2026 With New Flavors Like Zesty Ranch, Honey Mustard, And Hot Buffalo
Goldfish is kicking off 2026 and leaning harder into bold, playful snacking. The iconic cracker brand is expanding its lineup with new formats and flavors…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox