Sorcery: You Can Separate the Dough in Cookie Dough Ice Cream to Make an Actual Cookie

The first time I had cookie dough ice cream, my eyes lit up and I pondered the glory of this 2-in-1 dessert. It’s a flavor I associate with summers, childhood and everything right in the world. So, when I heard someone tried separating the precious dough from the vanilla ice cream, I did a double take. Why would anyone want to mess with perfection?

Apparently, because food science. Joe Satran of HuffPo Taste embarked on a mission to discover if it was possible to bake cookies using the cookie dough in cookie dough ice cream. Despite his initial doubt, the results were quite fantastic. Satran tested different brands from his local convenience store including Edy’s, Edy’s Maxx, Turkey Hill and Ben & Jerry’s.

After using a fine-mesh strainer to mine for the precious cookie dough pieces, the dough was then formed into little mounds and popped in the oven. 15 minutes later what he got was “100 percent recognizable” chocolate chip cookies that were a “little dry and sweet.”

Even the ice cream from the original pint was used to make the cookie dough sandwich.

cookie-dough-ice-cream-sandwich

Not too shabby.

Picthx Huffpo Taste

More content

Products
Snoop Dogg Will Pay You $10K A Month To Taste Ice Cream
Finding out that Snoop Dogg has a family-owned ice cream company and is currently looking for an official ice cream taste tester was not on…
,
Culture
Craig Robinson Reveals Just How Much Food Actors Get On TV Sets
Craig Robinson is someone you know, even if you weren’t paying attention to his memorably hilarious and zany characters in classic shows like The Office…
,
Products
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Is Getting A ‘Swicy’ Chamoy Makeover
This might be the most unexpected fusion-ha! of 2026. Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Chamoy Mega, the #1 chamoy brand in the U.S. and Mexico, are…
,
Burger
We Deliver!

Enter your email address below and we'll deliver our top stories straight to your inbox